FiveBar › NHL › Columbus Blue Jackets at New York Islanders › Recap
Columbus Blue Jackets 1, New York Islanders 5 (FINAL)
NHL recap

Schaefer's hat trick lifts Islanders past Blue Jackets

New York Islanders 5, Columbus Blue Jackets 1 · NHL · Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Published · Updated · Eastern Time

Matthew Schaefer scored three goals, including the winner, and the New York Islanders beat the Columbus Blue Jackets 5–1 on Tuesday.

The Islanders led 1–0 after the first period and 2–0 after two periods. Anthony Duclair opened the scoring for the Islanders in the final minute of the first period on the power play. Schaefer scored the winner 1 minute into the second period, making it 2–0. Schaefer sealed it with an empty-net goal 16 minutes into the third period.

A. DeAngelo and Duclair had a goal and an assist each, and Mathew Barzal had two assists. Zach Werenski scored for the Blue Jackets. Schaefer has nine goals for the Islanders this season.

The Islanders scored once on the power play. The officials called two penalties, both against the Blue Jackets.

It was the 28th hat trick of the 2026–27 season. The Islanders moved to 10–6–4 (24 points) with the home win; the Blue Jackets are 7–12–0 (14 points). The Islanders have won three straight, while the Blue Jackets have lost five in a row. It was the 54th meeting of the teams in our records since 2008–09; the Islanders have won 32 of them and the Blue Jackets 22.

Both play again on Thursday, November 19: the Islanders visit the Jets, the Blue Jackets visit the Blackhawks.

Game highlights the NHL's official video

Watch highlightsBlue Jackets 1, Islanders 5Official NHL video · plays from YouTube

Box score by period

Team123T
Blue Jackets0011
Islanders1135

Game flow goals and penalties · minutes gone in the period

  1. 1st period
  2. PENALTYCole SillingerSlashing
    17'
  3. GOAL · PPAnthony DuclairAssists: Mathew Barzal, A. DeAngelo
    19'0–1
  4. 2nd period
  5. GOALMatthew SchaeferUnassisted
    1'0–2
  6. 3rd period
  7. GOALZach WerenskiAssists: Kent Johnson, Luca Del Bel Belluz
    1'1–2
  8. GOALMatthew SchaeferAssists: Ryan Pulock, Anthony Duclair
    7'1–3
  9. PENALTYDelay of game
    7'
  10. GOALA. DeAngeloAssists: Mathew Barzal, Matias Maccelli
    11'1–4
  11. GOAL · ENMatthew SchaeferAssists: Simon Holmstrom, Bo Horvat
    16'1–5

Team stats this game

Blue JacketsIslanders

Scoring

1Goals5
2Assists8
0Power-play goals1
0Shorthanded goals0
0Empty-net goals1

Discipline

2Penalties0

Blue Jackets vs Islanders: every meeting in our files →

Box score and game page →Columbus Blue Jackets →New York Islanders →NHL scores and standings →All news →
Talk this game on DiscordEvery league has its channel on the FiveBar Discord: game talk, the numbers and the night's recaps.Join freeThink you can call the next one?Join the free tipster beta: every pick locked before the game and counted on a public board. 21+.