FiveBar › NHL › New York Islanders at Toronto Maple Leafs › Recap
New York Islanders 4, Toronto Maple Leafs 1 (FINAL)
NHL recap

Islanders beat Maple Leafs 4–1

New York Islanders 4, Toronto Maple Leafs 1 · NHL · Saturday, October 17, 2026

Published · Updated · Eastern Time

The New York Islanders beat the Toronto Maple Leafs 4–1 on Saturday.

The Islanders led 1–0 after the first period and 2–0 after two periods. Anthony Duclair opened the scoring for the Islanders 8 minutes into the first period. Bo Horvat scored the winner 18 minutes into the second period, making it 2–0. Simon Holmstrom sealed it with an empty-net goal 17 minutes into the third period.

Holmstrom finished with two goals and Horvat had a goal and an assist. Colton Sissons scored for the Maple Leafs. Holmstrom has three goals for the Islanders this season.

Neither team scored on the power play. The officials called five penalties, three against the Islanders and two against the Maple Leafs.

The Islanders moved to 4–3–1 (9 points) with the road win; the Maple Leafs are 3–4–2 (8 points). The Maple Leafs have gone three games without a win. It was the 56th meeting of the teams in our records since 2008–09; the Islanders have won 29 of them and the Maple Leafs 27. This season the Islanders have won one of the two meetings.

Next on the schedule: the Maple Leafs host the Sharks on Monday, October 19, and the Islanders host the Ducks on Tuesday, October 20.

Box score by period

Team123T
Islanders1124
Maple Leafs0011

Game flow goals and penalties · minutes gone in the period

  1. 1st period
  2. GOALAnthony DuclairAssists: Jean-Gabriel Pageau
    8'1–0
  3. PENALTYDarren RaddyshTripping
    16'
  4. PENALTYEaston CowanDelay of game
    18'
  5. 2nd period
  6. GOALBo HorvatAssists: Kyle Palmieri
    18'2–0
  7. PENALTYAdam PelechInterference
    19'
  8. 3rd period
  9. PENALTYEmil HeinemanTripping
    1'
  10. GOALColton SissonsAssists: Troy Stecher, Easton Cowan
    3'2–1
  11. PENALTYMatthew SchaeferDelay of game
    10'
  12. GOALSimon HolmstromAssists: Bo Horvat, Matthew Schaefer
    14'3–1
  13. GOAL · ENSimon HolmstromUnassisted
    17'4–1

Team stats this game

IslandersMaple Leafs

Scoring

4Goals1
4Assists2
0Power-play goals0
0Shorthanded goals0
1Empty-net goals0

Discipline

3Penalties2

Islanders vs Maple Leafs: every meeting in our files →

Box score and game page →New York Islanders →Toronto Maple Leafs →NHL scores and standings →All news →
Talk this game on DiscordEvery league has its channel on the FiveBar Discord: game talk, the numbers and the night's recaps.Join freeThink you can call the next one?Join the free tipster beta: every pick locked before the game and counted on a public board. 21+.