FiveBar › NHL › Tampa Bay Lightning at New York Islanders › Recap
Tampa Bay Lightning 5, New York Islanders 3 (FINAL)
NHL recap

Hagel's hat trick lifts Lightning past Islanders

Tampa Bay Lightning 5, New York Islanders 3 · NHL · Saturday, October 10, 2026

Published · Updated · Eastern Time

Brandon Hagel scored three goals, including the winner, and the Tampa Bay Lightning beat the New York Islanders 5–3 on Saturday.

The Lightning led 2–0 after the first period and it was tied 3–3 after two periods. Jake Guentzel opened the scoring for the Lightning 5 minutes into the first period. Hagel broke a 3–3 tie 18 minutes into the third period, set up by Max Crozier and Ryan McDonagh. Hagel sealed it with an empty-net goal 18 minutes into the third period.

Hagel finished with a hat trick and an assist. Guentzel had two goals, and Crozier and Nikita Kucherov had two assists each. For the Islanders, A. DeAngelo had a goal and an assist. Brayden Schenn and Jean-Gabriel Pageau also scored. Hagel has four goals for the Lightning this season and Guentzel three.

Both teams scored once on the power play. The officials called eight penalties, three against the Lightning and five against the Islanders, among them two fighting majors.

It was the fifth hat trick of the 2026–27 season and the first by a Lightning player. The Lightning moved to 4–1–0 (8 points) with the road win; the Islanders are 2–3–0 (4 points). The Lightning have won four straight. It was the 74th meeting of the teams in our records since 2008–09; the Lightning have won 41 of them and the Islanders 33.

Both play again on Tuesday, October 13: the Lightning visit the Rangers, the Islanders host the Canucks.

Box score by period

Team123T
Lightning2125
Islanders0303

Game flow goals and penalties · minutes gone in the period

  1. 1st period
  2. GOALJake GuentzelUnassisted
    5'1–0
  3. GOALBrandon HagelAssists: Victor Hedman, Max Crozier
    15'2–0
  4. PENALTYRyan PulockTripping
    17'
  5. PENALTYAdam PelechTripping
    19'
  6. 2nd period
  7. GOALA. DeAngeloAssists: Ondrej Palat
    6'2–1
  8. PENALTYEmil HeinemanTripping
    6'
  9. GOAL · PPJake GuentzelAssists: Nikita Kucherov, Brandon Hagel
    7'3–1
  10. PENALTYPontus HolmbergHooking
    8'
  11. PENALTYLogan StanleyFighting
    10'
  12. PENALTYScott SabourinFighting
    10'
  13. GOALJean-Gabriel PageauAssists: Matthew Schaefer, A. DeAngelo
    11'3–2
  14. PENALTYVictor EklundCross-checking
    12'
  15. PENALTYCharle-Edouard D'AstousCross-checking
    18'
  16. GOAL · PPBrayden SchennAssists: Bo Horvat, Matias Maccelli
    19'3–3
  17. 3rd period
  18. GOALBrandon HagelAssists: Max Crozier, Ryan McDonagh
    18'4–3
  19. GOAL · ENBrandon HagelAssists: Anthony Cirelli, Nikita Kucherov
    18'5–3

Team stats this game

LightningIslanders

Scoring

5Goals3
8Assists5
1Power-play goals1
0Shorthanded goals0
1Empty-net goals0

Discipline

3Penalties5

Lightning vs Islanders: every meeting in our files →

Box score and game page →Tampa Bay Lightning →New York Islanders →NHL scores and standings →All news →
Talk this game on DiscordEvery league has its channel on the FiveBar Discord: game talk, the numbers and the night's recaps.Join freeThink you can call the next one?Join the free tipster beta: every pick locked before the game and counted on a public board. 21+.