FiveBar › MLS › New York City FC at Orlando City SC › Recap
New York City FC 2, Orlando City SC 2 (FINAL)
MLS recap

Late Jonathan Shore goal earns New York City FC 2–2 tie with Orlando City SC

New York City FC 2, Orlando City SC 2 · MLS · Saturday, October 24, 2026

Published · Updated · Eastern Time

Orlando City SC and New York City FC tied 2–2 in MLS at Exploria Stadium on Saturday, October 24. A late equalizer in stoppage time (90+9) earned the visitors the tie. The sides have now met 27 times in the MLS regular season since 2012: Orlando City SC has won 6, New York City FC 12 and 9 games were tied. The previous one, on March 7, 2026, was a 5–0 home win for New York City FC.

Alonso Martinez put the road team ahead in the 18th minute from Hannes Wolf's pass. Antoine Griezmann tied the game for the hosts in the 32nd minute, set up by Martin Ojeda. The sides went in tied at 1–1. Griezmann now has 13 league goals this season, in 15 appearances.

Ojeda turned the game around for the home team in the 49th minute from Vinícius Nogueira's pass, making it 2–1. Ojeda now has 16 league goals this season, in 25 appearances. Talles Magno missed a penalty for the visitors in the 81st minute. Substitute Jonathan Shore equalized for New York City FC in stoppage time (90+9), set up by James Sands, making it 2–2.

Both teams had 8 shots, 4 on goal each. The road team had most of the ball and won 3 corners to 1. Tomas Romero made 1 save for the visitors. Referee Elijio Arreguin showed 5 yellow cards.

The result leaves Orlando City SC on 42 points from 31 games and New York City FC on 35. The road team has now gone six league games without a win. In their last five league games the hosts have won 2, tied 2 and lost 1, while the visitors have tied 3 and lost 2.

Box score by period

Team1st2ndT
New York City112
Orlando City112

Game flow goals, cards and substitutions

  1. 1st half
  2. GOALAlonso MartinezAssist: Hannes Wolf
    18'1–0
  3. SUB↑ Tomas Romero↓ Matthew Freese
    28'
  4. GOALAntoine GriezmannAssist: Martin Ojeda
    32'1–1
  5. YELLOW CARDVinicius Nogueira
    38'
  6. YELLOW CARDJames Sands
    44'
  7. 2nd half
  8. SUB↑ Joran Gerbet↓ Braian Ojeda
    46'
  9. GOALMartin OjedaAssist: Vinicius Nogueira
    49'1–2
  10. SUB↑ Marco Pašalić↓ Justin Ellis
    60'
  11. YELLOW CARDIago Teodoro
    63'
  12. SUB↑ Adrián Marín↓ Vinicius Nogueira
    71'
  13. SUB↑ Talles Magno↓ Agustin Ojeda
    71'
  14. SUB↑ Jonathan Shore↓ Aiden O'Neill
    71'
  15. SUB↑ Zakaria Taifi↓ Iago Teodoro
    71'
  16. YELLOW CARDWilder Cartagena
    78'
  17. NO GOALTalles MagnoMissed Penalty
    81'
  18. SUB↑ Bénie Adama Traoré↓ Hannes Wolf
    82'
  19. SUB↑ Malachi Jones↓ Alonso Martinez
    82'
  20. SUB↑ Daryl Dike↓ Martin Ojeda
    83'
  21. YELLOW CARDEduard Atuesta
    86'
  22. GOALJonathan ShoreAssist: James Sands
    90+9'2–2

Team stats this game

New York CityOrlando City

Shots

8Shots8
4On target4
2Off target1
2Blocked3
8Inside the box6
0Outside the box2

Attack

3Corners1
1Offsides0

Passing

271Passes274
245Accurate passes243

Discipline

9Fouls10
1Yellow cards1
0Red cards0

Goalkeeping

2Saves3

Lineups starting elevens

New York City · 4-2-3-1
49Freese↓28'
22O'Toole
6Sands
13Martins
24Gray
8Perea
21O'Neill↓71'
17Wolf↓82'
7Mercau
26Ojeda↓71'
16Martínez↓82'
Orlando City · 4-2-3-1
71Crépeau
27Nogueira↓71'
57Iago↓71'
4Brekalo
77Angulo
16Cartagena
8Ojeda↓46'
10Ojeda↓83'
20Atuesta
22Ellis↓60'
7Griezmann

New York City On: T. Romero 28', J. Shore 71', Talles Magno 71', B. Traoré 82', M. Jones 82' · Coach: P. Jansen

Orlando City On: D. Dike 83', Joran Gerbet 46', Marco Pasalic 60', Z. Taifi 71', Adrián Marín 71' · Coach: M. Perelman

Box score and game page →New York City FC →Orlando City SC →MLS scores and standings →All news →
Talk this game on DiscordEvery league has its channel on the FiveBar Discord: game talk, the numbers and the night's recaps.Join freeThink you can call the next one?Join the free tipster beta: every pick locked before the game and counted on a public board. 21+.